Its not up to you. its racist if it offends someone and is racially specific. That's exactly how the comment was used, why it was highlighted as racist, and why he apologised.Striker wrote:Take your over reactionary PC bullshit somewhere else, pie muncher. It's not racist and deep down if you have any sense you'd know it.
nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
- Xman
- Coach
- Posts: 13919
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 7:09 pm
- Team: Essendon
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
King-Eliagh: ...I believe [RL] is popular in all the other states and territories, bar tasmania.
-
- Seniors
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:24 pm
- Team: North Melbourne
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Ahh the last bastions of racism."I didnt mean it to be racist" and "This is politically correct bullshit"Xman wrote:Its not up to you. its racist if it offends someone and is racially specific. That's exactly how the comment was used, why it was highlighted as racist, and why he apologised.Striker wrote:Take your over reactionary PC bullshit somewhere else, pie muncher. It's not racist and deep down if you have any sense you'd know it.
-
- Seniors
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:24 pm
- Team: North Melbourne
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
It is simple it is you that is trying to create the grey area for the young man to hide in. As I said I believe he is not a racist just a uneducated moron with no sense of tact.But undeniably his comments were of a racist nature. To try to suggest otherwise is pandering to those who thinks this kind of behaviour is above board. But thats right "I didnt mean to be racist and this is PC bullshit".King-Eliagh wrote:Again all's you've got is your one way traffic, simplifying a highly complex issue. Do you ever wonder why i often refer to you yobbos as simpletons? I did not use and dont defend the 'i didnt mean it to be racist' argument at all. I'm highlighting this is not black and white and it definitely aint what you keep dribbling on about, it just aint so simple.pookus wrote:Sorry mate that comment shows your ignorance using the excuse biggots have always used.I didnt mean it to be racist.If it offends on a racial level it is racist any court of law will tell you this.Your intention is secondary to the fact as many men have found out in sexual harasment charges. Not one court in the land would defend your right to use the term Curry muncher.This is fact.King-Eliagh wrote:Stewie,
The Maori NRL player apologised "if his comment offended anyone". He did not apologise for "making a racist statement" as you and all your other bogan pie munchers think.
Xman,
You are appearing more gumby than usual in this thread. Think boy think! A racist comment, nor bullying nor sexual harassment is not simply about the manner in which they are 'received', but, one could argue, much more about the intention in which it is dealt. As I've correctly argued all along in this thread, its not all black and white like you pie chompin gonad brained southerners think. If one were to simply go by Xman's statements we could have illegitimate racism claims paid out right left and center, simply because one 'feels' something is racist. Victim mentality would reign and we'd all be far far far worse off.
Now let us all thank god the only position of power Xman holds is in these forums and not in the real world
-
- Coach
- Posts: 1053
- Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:14 pm
- Team: Melbourne Storm
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
It's NOT racially specific!!! How do you know that's how it was used? I eat curry! Does that make me a curry muncher? YES! Am I offended? NO! The apology only came because of some princesses who decided to be precious and instead of slapping the whiners across the face and telling them to grow a set, he lost his own guts. This world is BULLSHIT!Xman wrote:Its not up to you. its racist if it offends someone and is racially specific. That's exactly how the comment was used, why it was highlighted as racist, and why he apologised.Striker wrote:Take your over reactionary PC bullshit somewhere else, pie muncher. It's not racist and deep down if you have any sense you'd know it.
And you can take your comment, Pook, and shove it up your arse. Next you'll be telling us to say Happy Holidays instead of Merry Christmas right? Do me a favour and grow a set yourself, huh?
- Xman
- Coach
- Posts: 13919
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 7:09 pm
- Team: Essendon
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Again, for the slow, it doesn't matter how it was used, only how it was received. And if youre too stupid to realise curry munchers is racially specific you really are a dumb racist!Striker wrote:It's NOT racially specific!!! How do you know that's how it was used? I eat curry! Does that make me a curry muncher? YES! Am I offended? NO! The apology only came because of some princesses who decided to be precious and instead of slapping the whiners across the face and telling them to grow a set, he lost his own guts. This world is BULLSHIT!Xman wrote:Its not up to you. its racist if it offends someone and is racially specific. That's exactly how the comment was used, why it was highlighted as racist, and why he apologised.Striker wrote:Take your over reactionary PC bullshit somewhere else, pie muncher. It's not racist and deep down if you have any sense you'd know it.
And you can take your comment, Pook, and shove it up your arse. Next you'll be telling us to say Happy Holidays instead of Merry Christmas right? Do me a favour and grow a set yourself, huh?
King-Eliagh: ...I believe [RL] is popular in all the other states and territories, bar tasmania.
-
- Seniors
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:24 pm
- Team: North Melbourne
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Currymuncher is not racially specific So why was it directed at 2 Indian girls. This world is bullshit for those who cant get a grip of reality.This aint 1960's white Australia champ welcome to the new world I'm sorry your antiquated views no longer belong. But hey theres an organisation that wear white sheets that totally agree with your view on political correctness.They find its a mighty shield to hide behind. :DStriker wrote:It's NOT racially specific!!! How do you know that's how it was used? I eat curry! Does that make me a curry muncher? YES! Am I offended? NO! The apology only came because of some princesses who decided to be precious and instead of slapping the whiners across the face and telling them to grow a set, he lost his own guts. This world is BULLSHIT!Xman wrote:Its not up to you. its racist if it offends someone and is racially specific. That's exactly how the comment was used, why it was highlighted as racist, and why he apologised.Striker wrote:Take your over reactionary PC bullshit somewhere else, pie muncher. It's not racist and deep down if you have any sense you'd know it.
And you can take your comment, Pook, and shove it up your arse. Next you'll be telling us to say Happy Holidays instead of Merry Christmas right? Do me a favour and grow a set yourself, huh?
- King-Eliagh
- Coach
- Posts: 13126
- Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 7:23 pm
- Team: Parramatta
- Location:
- Has thanked: 16 times
- Been liked: 11 times
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
=D> =D> =D>
Alllllrighty then folks, its been quite a thorough lil chat here so allow me to sum up the situation.
Innnnn the pink corner we have Xman, pookus and stewie.
Annnd in the black corner we have yours truly and striker.
KE came out playing coy and threw a few cheeky light jabs. To which Xman and stewie immediately overlooked the situation, letting their emotions get the better of them and throwing wild infuriated haymakers with only their left hand i.e. racism can only be assessed by those who it is directed at. KE evaded easily and with mocking disdain for his opponents, laughing at their incompetence and hurling numerous pies with both right and left hands, landing them square in the gobs of all three pink fighters, following it up with throwing a most accurate left hook in stating that the comment could most accruately be defined as an ethnic slur. In comes pookus, also only throwing lefts but, keeping his emotions in check he manages to land a few, learning KE a few lessons, albeit simple ones. Striker rolls in with a head full of steam, knocking stewie out with a wild haymaker, leaving the pink sheilas with only Xman and his more intelligent counterpart pookus. But alas the pair continue to throw only their left hands, showing no understanding of the complexities of the fight. Striker continues throwing wild haymakers until finally running out of steam, falling in a heap stating "this world is bullshit"as he spits his bloodied mouthgaurd into the crowd. At this point KE steps in, looks at his opposition - Xman bloodied and swollen looks very much the gonad brained tool KE took him for, while pookus, his right arm limper than his grandpas penis, looks like he will only continue with his left - and generously calls off the fight.
All in all it was a substandard fight with KE dominating and only pookus from the pink team landing any blows of substance. Unlike the 19th century where Xman and pookus belong (stewie belongs back in the neandrthal days), the concepts of race and racism are not cut and dry/black and white. We live in a world where spaces are much more contested and race, with all the movement and mixing in a globalised world, is becoming a much less valid concept - and its arguable it was an invalid concept all along. An example. One can use the term 'blackfellas'' in the same manner in which many ''non-blackfellas'' use the term ''whitefellas''. These terms have in the past been considered racist but, without any negative adjective such as ''fucking'' attached they arent considered racist terms today. To state the use of "curry munchers"' to two women who most likely identify as Australian women from an Indian background in the context of a cooking show can not be considered point blank racism with the information we had at hand. At worst it is an ethnic slur, which I said all along.
Thank you, and good night.
Alllllrighty then folks, its been quite a thorough lil chat here so allow me to sum up the situation.
Innnnn the pink corner we have Xman, pookus and stewie.
Annnd in the black corner we have yours truly and striker.
KE came out playing coy and threw a few cheeky light jabs. To which Xman and stewie immediately overlooked the situation, letting their emotions get the better of them and throwing wild infuriated haymakers with only their left hand i.e. racism can only be assessed by those who it is directed at. KE evaded easily and with mocking disdain for his opponents, laughing at their incompetence and hurling numerous pies with both right and left hands, landing them square in the gobs of all three pink fighters, following it up with throwing a most accurate left hook in stating that the comment could most accruately be defined as an ethnic slur. In comes pookus, also only throwing lefts but, keeping his emotions in check he manages to land a few, learning KE a few lessons, albeit simple ones. Striker rolls in with a head full of steam, knocking stewie out with a wild haymaker, leaving the pink sheilas with only Xman and his more intelligent counterpart pookus. But alas the pair continue to throw only their left hands, showing no understanding of the complexities of the fight. Striker continues throwing wild haymakers until finally running out of steam, falling in a heap stating "this world is bullshit"as he spits his bloodied mouthgaurd into the crowd. At this point KE steps in, looks at his opposition - Xman bloodied and swollen looks very much the gonad brained tool KE took him for, while pookus, his right arm limper than his grandpas penis, looks like he will only continue with his left - and generously calls off the fight.
All in all it was a substandard fight with KE dominating and only pookus from the pink team landing any blows of substance. Unlike the 19th century where Xman and pookus belong (stewie belongs back in the neandrthal days), the concepts of race and racism are not cut and dry/black and white. We live in a world where spaces are much more contested and race, with all the movement and mixing in a globalised world, is becoming a much less valid concept - and its arguable it was an invalid concept all along. An example. One can use the term 'blackfellas'' in the same manner in which many ''non-blackfellas'' use the term ''whitefellas''. These terms have in the past been considered racist but, without any negative adjective such as ''fucking'' attached they arent considered racist terms today. To state the use of "curry munchers"' to two women who most likely identify as Australian women from an Indian background in the context of a cooking show can not be considered point blank racism with the information we had at hand. At worst it is an ethnic slur, which I said all along.
Thank you, and good night.
xman wrote:KE, why is an even comp important?
- Xman
- Coach
- Posts: 13919
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 7:09 pm
- Team: Essendon
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
KE, comparing an argument he clearly lost, to a violent brawl. Given his sporting preference why am I not surprised?King-Eliagh wrote:=D> =D> =D>
Alllllrighty then folks, its been quite a thorough lil chat here so allow me to sum up the situation.
Innnnn the pink corner we have Xman, pookus and stewie.
Annnd in the black corner we have yours truly and striker.
KE came out playing coy and threw a few cheeky light jabs. To which Xman and stewie immediately overlooked the situation, letting their emotions get the better of them and throwing wild infuriated haymakers with only their left hand i.e. racism can only be assessed by those who it is directed at. KE evaded easily and with mocking disdain for his opponents, laughing at their incompetence and hurling numerous pies with both right and left hands, landing them square in the gobs of all three pink fighters, following it up with throwing a most accurate left hook in stating that the comment could most accruately be defined as an ethnic slur. In comes pookus, also only throwing lefts but, keeping his emotions in check he manages to land a few, learning KE a few lessons, albeit simple ones. Striker rolls in with a head full of steam, knocking stewie out with a wild haymaker, leaving the pink sheilas with only Xman and his more intelligent counterpart pookus. But alas the pair continue to throw only their left hands, showing no understanding of the complexities of the fight. Striker continues throwing wild haymakers until finally running out of steam, falling in a heap stating "this world is bullshit"as he spits his bloodied mouthgaurd into the crowd. At this point KE steps in, looks at his opposition - Xman bloodied and swollen looks very much the gonad brained tool KE took him for, while pookus, his right arm limper than his grandpas penis, looks like he will only continue with his left - and generously calls off the fight.
All in all it was a substandard fight with KE dominating and only pookus from the pink team landing any blows of substance. Unlike the 19th century where Xman and pookus belong (stewie belongs back in the neandrthal days), the concepts of race and racism are not cut and dry/black and white. We live in a world where spaces are much more contested and race, with all the movement and mixing in a globalised world, is becoming a much less valid concept - and its arguable it was an invalid concept all along. An example. One can use the term 'blackfellas'' in the same manner in which many ''non-blackfellas'' use the term ''whitefellas''. These terms have in the past been considered racist but, without any negative adjective such as ''fucking'' attached they arent considered racist terms today. To state the use of "curry munchers"' to two women who most likely identify as Australian women from an Indian background in the context of a cooking show can not be considered point blank racism with the information we had at hand. At worst it is an ethnic slur, which I said all along.
Thank you, and good night.
King-Eliagh: ...I believe [RL] is popular in all the other states and territories, bar tasmania.
-
- Seniors
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:24 pm
- Team: North Melbourne
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Nice =D> =D> =D> =D> =D> Ive said all along the young mans not a racist but the comment was.Your right in an ambiguous world the lines are blurred easy so in my experience its best to stay away from the edge.The young man in question no doubt discovered this.On another matter I have to say the way you talk yourself up there you could be DJ KE in the house. As ive been saying what you concluded with all along I would say the light hands and the quick feet give me this one on points.King-Eliagh wrote:=D> =D> =D>
Alllllrighty then folks, its been quite a thorough lil chat here so allow me to sum up the situation.
Innnnn the pink corner we have Xman, pookus and stewie.
Annnd in the black corner we have yours truly and striker.
KE came out playing coy and threw a few cheeky light jabs. To which Xman and stewie immediately overlooked the situation, letting their emotions get the better of them and throwing wild infuriated haymakers with only their left hand i.e. racism can only be assessed by those who it is directed at. KE evaded easily and with mocking disdain for his opponents, laughing at their incompetence and hurling numerous pies with both right and left hands, landing them square in the gobs of all three pink fighters, following it up with throwing a most accurate left hook in stating that the comment could most accruately be defined as an ethnic slur. In comes pookus, also only throwing lefts but, keeping his emotions in check he manages to land a few, learning KE a few lessons, albeit simple ones. Striker rolls in with a head full of steam, knocking stewie out with a wild haymaker, leaving the pink sheilas with only Xman and his more intelligent counterpart pookus. But alas the pair continue to throw only their left hands, showing no understanding of the complexities of the fight. Striker continues throwing wild haymakers until finally running out of steam, falling in a heap stating "this world is bullshit"as he spits his bloodied mouthgaurd into the crowd. At this point KE steps in, looks at his opposition - Xman bloodied and swollen looks very much the gonad brained tool KE took him for, while pookus, his right arm limper than his grandpas penis, looks like he will only continue with his left - and generously calls off the fight.
All in all it was a substandard fight with KE dominating and only pookus from the pink team landing any blows of substance. Unlike the 19th century where Xman and pookus belong (stewie belongs back in the neandrthal days), the concepts of race and racism are not cut and dry/black and white. We live in a world where spaces are much more contested and race, with all the movement and mixing in a globalised world, is becoming a much less valid concept - and its arguable it was an invalid concept all along. An example. One can use the term 'blackfellas'' in the same manner in which many ''non-blackfellas'' use the term ''whitefellas''. These terms have in the past been considered racist but, without any negative adjective such as ''fucking'' attached they arent considered racist terms today. To state the use of "curry munchers"' to two women who most likely identify as Australian women from an Indian background in the context of a cooking show can not be considered point blank racism with the information we had at hand. At worst it is an ethnic slur, which I said all along.
Thank you, and good night.
-
- Coach
- Posts: 1053
- Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:14 pm
- Team: Melbourne Storm
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Here comes another wild haymaker..... (LMAO El! Riping post!)
IIRC those two Indian girls were being total morons! The swipe at them could easily have been sexist, but no the safe ball was played with "curry muncher". And yet the two Indian girls who were already established as princesses bleated "racism" and here come the goody two shoes into bat to try and knock out what was essentially non racist thoroughly deserved RIB!
So aren't we allowed to joke around anymore? PRECIOUS!!!!!! Grow a set you dickheads!
IIRC those two Indian girls were being total morons! The swipe at them could easily have been sexist, but no the safe ball was played with "curry muncher". And yet the two Indian girls who were already established as princesses bleated "racism" and here come the goody two shoes into bat to try and knock out what was essentially non racist thoroughly deserved RIB!
So aren't we allowed to joke around anymore? PRECIOUS!!!!!! Grow a set you dickheads!
-
- Seniors
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:24 pm
- Team: North Melbourne
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Just stay on the mat son When is saying something racially insensitive the safe option And your right there were so many ways to hang shit on these two and he chose the easiest and least intelligent option. He got slapped next time hell just call them the fuckwits that they were with no reference to colour,creed or sex.Lesson learnt.Striker wrote:Here comes another wild haymaker..... (LMAO El! Riping post!)
IIRC those two Indian girls were being total morons! The swipe at them could easily have been sexist, but no the safe ball was played with "curry muncher". And yet the two Indian girls who were already established as princesses bleated "racism" and here come the goody two shoes into bat to try and knock out what was essentially non racist thoroughly deserved RIB!
So aren't we allowed to joke around anymore? PRECIOUS!!!!!! Grow a set you dickheads!
- Xman
- Coach
- Posts: 13919
- Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2011 7:09 pm
- Team: Essendon
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
His comment sure didnt seem like a joke!Striker wrote:Here comes another wild haymaker..... (LMAO El! Riping post!)
IIRC those two Indian girls were being total morons! The swipe at them could easily have been sexist, but no the safe ball was played with "curry muncher". And yet the two Indian girls who were already established as princesses bleated "racism" and here come the goody two shoes into bat to try and knock out what was essentially non racist thoroughly deserved RIB!
So aren't we allowed to joke around anymore? PRECIOUS!!!!!! Grow a set you dickheads!
But again, typical excuses from an apologist: "I didnt mean it" " stop being so sensitive" "it was a joke"!
Pathetic!
King-Eliagh: ...I believe [RL] is popular in all the other states and territories, bar tasmania.
-
- Seniors
- Posts: 460
- Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2012 4:24 pm
- Team: North Melbourne
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
Oh and the pink reference we need to have a chat on homophobia invite Straight Dave along his redneck needs some whitewashingpookus wrote:Nice =D> =D> =D> =D> =D> Ive said all along the young mans not a racist but the comment was.Your right in an ambiguous world the lines are blurred easy so in my experience its best to stay away from the edge.The young man in question no doubt discovered this.On another matter I have to say the way you talk yourself up there you could be DJ KE in the house. As ive been saying what you concluded with all along I would say the light hands and the quick feet give me this one on points.King-Eliagh wrote:=D> =D> =D>
Alllllrighty then folks, its been quite a thorough lil chat here so allow me to sum up the situation.
Innnnn the pink corner we have Xman, pookus and stewie.
Annnd in the black corner we have yours truly and striker.
KE came out playing coy and threw a few cheeky light jabs. To which Xman and stewie immediately overlooked the situation, letting their emotions get the better of them and throwing wild infuriated haymakers with only their left hand i.e. racism can only be assessed by those who it is directed at. KE evaded easily and with mocking disdain for his opponents, laughing at their incompetence and hurling numerous pies with both right and left hands, landing them square in the gobs of all three pink fighters, following it up with throwing a most accurate left hook in stating that the comment could most accruately be defined as an ethnic slur. In comes pookus, also only throwing lefts but, keeping his emotions in check he manages to land a few, learning KE a few lessons, albeit simple ones. Striker rolls in with a head full of steam, knocking stewie out with a wild haymaker, leaving the pink sheilas with only Xman and his more intelligent counterpart pookus. But alas the pair continue to throw only their left hands, showing no understanding of the complexities of the fight. Striker continues throwing wild haymakers until finally running out of steam, falling in a heap stating "this world is bullshit"as he spits his bloodied mouthgaurd into the crowd. At this point KE steps in, looks at his opposition - Xman bloodied and swollen looks very much the gonad brained tool KE took him for, while pookus, his right arm limper than his grandpas penis, looks like he will only continue with his left - and generously calls off the fight.
All in all it was a substandard fight with KE dominating and only pookus from the pink team landing any blows of substance. Unlike the 19th century where Xman and pookus belong (stewie belongs back in the neandrthal days), the concepts of race and racism are not cut and dry/black and white. We live in a world where spaces are much more contested and race, with all the movement and mixing in a globalised world, is becoming a much less valid concept - and its arguable it was an invalid concept all along. An example. One can use the term 'blackfellas'' in the same manner in which many ''non-blackfellas'' use the term ''whitefellas''. These terms have in the past been considered racist but, without any negative adjective such as ''fucking'' attached they arent considered racist terms today. To state the use of "curry munchers"' to two women who most likely identify as Australian women from an Indian background in the context of a cooking show can not be considered point blank racism with the information we had at hand. At worst it is an ethnic slur, which I said all along.
Thank you, and good night.
- QueenslandISAFL
- Captain
- Posts: 586
- Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2012 2:43 pm
- Team: Brisbane Lions
- Location: AFL Heartland (Brisbane)
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
typical nrl rednecks
NRL Fans = Basement Dwelling Virgins
-
- Coach
- Posts: 1053
- Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2012 9:14 pm
- Team: Melbourne Storm
- Location:
- Has thanked: 0
- Been liked: 0
Re: nRL players racist slur toward MKR couple
You're pathetic, X. I'm not apologising for anything! I meant everything I said and my statements are NOT a joke! His was and he had no need to apologise or anything! The two Indian girls are the ones who should be apologising for making a scene over what amounted to one big goose egg! God I hope they don't win the competition!Xman wrote:His comment sure didnt seem like a joke!Striker wrote:Here comes another wild haymaker..... (LMAO El! Riping post!)
IIRC those two Indian girls were being total morons! The swipe at them could easily have been sexist, but no the safe ball was played with "curry muncher". And yet the two Indian girls who were already established as princesses bleated "racism" and here come the goody two shoes into bat to try and knock out what was essentially non racist thoroughly deserved RIB!
So aren't we allowed to joke around anymore? PRECIOUS!!!!!! Grow a set you dickheads!
But again, typical excuses from an apologist: "I didnt mean it" " stop being so sensitive" "it was a joke"!
Pathetic!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Amazon [Bot], Bing [Bot] and 2 guests