BS file#36: The brawl at Bruce stadium was worse than Windy

[Xman]

Claim: The brawl at Bruce stadium was worse than the brawl at Windy Hill between Ess and Richmond

Claimant: TLPG

Challenger: Markzzz

Challenged: 6/9 1400hrs

[TLPG]

Subjective challenge and should be withdrawn.

[Xman]

viewtopic.php?f=33&t=2850

Here's a similar example. As you can see the responsibility is on the claimant to prove their claim so Id suggest you need to find proof

[TLPG]

Not relevant. That was a written work he was claiming. I'm not. Again, check your PM's.

[MarkZZZ]

Hey TLPG was there even an incident at Bruce Stadium in 1997 that you say you witnessed that "was worse" that the "Battle of Windy Hill" I say you need to find some proof ands that proof needs to show some major altercations or you will be wearing a BS point.


BTW whats with all this PM talk. I hope you are not trying to influence Xman's decision.

[TLPG]

I say, shut up, bully. I don't have to provide anything here.

[MarkZZZ]

No you don't "have" to provide anything but you will be provided with a BS point if you don't and also wear the tag of a "mug lier" to use your own terminology.

No proof = BS

[TLPG]

I am not a liar, bully. I don't have to prove anything, and I will not be getting a BS point for having an opinion as stated in the claim in the OP. This file is not about whether or not there was a fight. It's about whether the fight was worse than the one at Windy Hill.

[Xman]

I am not a liar, bully. I don't have to prove anything, and I will not be getting a BS point for having an opinion as stated in the claim in the OP. This file is not about whether or not there was a fight. It's about whether the fight was worse than the one at Windy Hill.

To be fair to all members you do need to find proof it happened. This was required of Dave and KE after their claim

[TLPG]

Xman, that is an unfair demand and deep down you know it is.

[MarkZZZ]

The request (you call it demand) is nothing out of the ordinary that has been asked of anyone else that has been to these pages and been required to support their claims/accusations. You my friend are not above everyone else and are subject to the same requirements.

If you are not going to provide any evidence/proof of your claim you should be awarded a BS point just like all the others that have their claim/accusations not supported by cold hard facts.

You seem to be saying that you cannot provide any support for your statement so I call upon Xman to not let this go on any longer and award the BS point and get it over and done with.

[TLPG]

No, Beau got a message as indicated on the main TFC showing from a reputable source that the fight did occur.

So that's the end of it. No BS point - no nothing.

[King-Eliagh]

"a message from a reputable source" as stated by beaussie

this file is pretty funny.

Mark, to overcome the most biased system in all the land you are one smart cookie. Bigups to you my man...if it comes through, which it very well may not...

TLPG, you know that if you receive a BS point, you're gunna be like all the others with a BS point. i.e. a LEAGUE supporter!

You're gunna be one of us TLPG! Marked as one of us! That BS point next to your name puts you with me, and raider etc. the good guys I dont think one of the AFL fans has ever received one

History in the making folks.

Xman? Check your pms...NOW!

[TLPG]

U mad?

[King-Eliagh]

It's not long now TLPG. Before you become....one of us

Wear your point with pride TLPG you bullshittting bastard