Options for a lopsided comp

[TLPG]

And North Melbourne SHOULD have beaten West Coast and only lost by 2 points!

[eelofwest]

Want to check the AFL ladder against the NRL ladder? And then try to say that again?

You are a pack of morons.

Incidentally, that was not a flogging between Carlton and Hawthorn.

Wow Melbourne storm just got there asses handed to them by the 11th team on the ladder..... now that is a real competition with upsets galore.

Tell me guys has the AFL got any upsets like this happening week in week out?

ROUND 18 NRL Any of the top 9 sides can win the NRL Premiership. =D>

1 Storm 12 4 0 2 165 28
2 Bulldogs 11 5 0 2 128 26
3 Broncos 10 6 0 2 84 24
4 Sharks 10 5 0 2 29 24
5 Cowboys 9 7 0 2 79 22
6 Sea Eagles 9 6 0 2 51 22
7 Rabbitohs 9 6 0 2 33 22
8 Warriors 8 8 0 2 32 20
9 Tigers 8 8 0 2 -4 20
10 Dragons 7 9 0 2 -44 18
11 Raiders 7 9 0 2 -59 18
12 Titans 6 10 0 2 -38 16
13 Knights 6 9 0 2 -45 16
14 Roosters 6 9 0 2 -120 16
15 Panthers 4 12 0 2 -130 12
16 Eels 3 12 0 2 -161 10

ROUND 15 AFL any of the top 5 can win the Flag

1 Sydney 14 11 0 3 146.13 44
2 West Coast 14 11 0 3 139.93 44
3 Adelaide 14 11 0 3 123.29 44
4 Collingwood 14 11 0 3 120.32 44
5 Essendon 14 10 0 4 127.63 40
6 Hawthorn 13 9 0 4 138.72 36
7 Geelong 13 8 0 5 112.78 32
8 St Kilda 14 7 0 7 121.26 28
9 Carlton 14 7 0 7 108.74 28
10 Richmond 14 7 0 7 107.70 28
11 North Melbourne 14 7 0 7 104.78 28
12 Brisbane 14 6 0 8 92.81 24
13 Fremantle 13 6 0 7 90.79 24
14 Bulldogs 13 5 0 8 79.38 20
15 Port Adelaide 14 4 0 10 81.78 16
16 Melbourne 14 2 0 12 63.59 8
17 Greater Western Sydney 13 1 0 12 47.53 4
18 Gold Coast 13 0 0 13 53.21 0
The basketcase league

NRL competition Wins hands down and the NRL is further into the season.

Who here think the Brisbane lions in 12th will beat sydney in 1st like what Canberra Raiders just did to Mel Storm? bahahahah not a chance..... =D>

The melbourne storm were thrashed by Canberra not just beaten thrashed, now tell me has any side in the AFL thrashed 1st place while they were sitting 12th on the ladder?????? hell to the NO

[Xman]

Collingwood were convincingly beaten by Carlton. essendon were thrashed by Stkilda.

[TLPG]

And Gold Coast gave Geelong a fright!

[eelofwest]

Collingwood were convincingly beaten by Carlton. essendon were thrashed by Stkilda.

Carl 85 beat Coll 62

Oh wow so your calling a 23 point loss for Coll a convincing win for Carlton???? DERPHERP

Stkilda are in 8th the Bombers in 6th, now tell me how that is even close to Canberra in 12th thrashing the Storm in 1st on the ladder........

So i ask again....

The melbourne storm were thrashed by Canberra not just beaten thrashed, (now tell me has any side in the AFL thrashed 1st place while they were sitting 12th on the ladder??????)hell to the NO

And Gold Coast gave Geelong a fright!

TPLG i am not going to waste my time with you.... read the question then post accordingly you dumb shit....

[TLPG]

Coward. Start addressing the facts I present instead on whining like a spoilt brat.

[Xman]

Collingwood were convincingly beaten by Carlton. essendon were thrashed by Stkilda.

Carl 85 beat Coll 62

Oh wow so your calling a 23 point loss for Coll a convincing win for Carlton???? DERPHERP

Stkilda are in 8th the Bombers in 6th, now tell me how that is even close to Canberra in 12th thrashing the Storm in 1st on the ladder........

So i ask again....

The melbourne storm were thrashed by Canberra not just beaten thrashed, (now tell me has any side in the AFL thrashed 1st place while they were sitting 12th on the ladder??????)hell to the NO

And Gold Coast gave Geelong a fright!

TPLG i am not going to waste my time with you.... read the question then post accordingly you dumb ****....

You fool! Essendon were 4th and Stkilda outside the 8 before that game. The effect of a close comp means 1 loss has a huge impact on ladder positions.

[eelofwest]

What a great even competition we have.. =D>

NRL 9 teams can win the Premiership.
W L D B PD Pts
1 Storm 12 5 0 2 161 28
2 Bulldogs 12 5 0 2 148 28
3 Broncos 11 6 0 2 86 26
4 Sharks 10 6 1 2 21 25
5 Cowboys 10 7 0 2 83 24
6 Rabbitohs 10 6 0 2 53 24
7 Sea Eagles 10 7 0 2 41 24
8 Tigers 9 8 0 2 4 22
9 Warriors 8 9 0 2 30 20
10 Dragons 8 9 0 2 -36 20
11 Titans 7 10 0 2 -26 18
12 Knights 7 10 0 2 -39 18
13 Raiders 7 10 0 2 -71 18
14 Roosters 6 9 1 2 -120 17
15 Panthers 4 13 0 2 -138 12
16 Eels 3 14 0 2 -197 10

Now compare that to this basketcase...

AFL 6 teams can win the Flag. 3 VFL sides on the bottom and no mans land from position 8 to 12.....
P W D L % Pts
1 Sydney 15 12 0 3 148.05 48
2 Adelaide 15 12 0 3 131.87 48
3 Collingwood 15 12 0 3 121.56 48
4 Hawthorn 15 11 0 4 157.00 44
5 West Coast 15 11 0 4 131.52 44
6 Essendon 15 11 0 4 130.00 44
7 Geelong 15 9 0 6 109.43 36
8 St Kilda 15 8 0 7 120.76 32
9 North Melbourne 15 8 0 7 107.97 32
10 Fremantle 15 8 0 7 97.60 32
11 Richmond 15 7 0 8 107.02 28
12 Carlton 15 7 0 8 103.72 28
13 Brisbane 15 6 0 9 92.42 24
14 Bulldogs 15 5 0 10 74.68 20
15 Port Adelaide 15 4 0 11 79.92 16
16 Melbourne 15 2 0 13 64.12 8
17 Gold Coast 15 1 0 14 57.84 4
18 Greater Western Sydney 15 1 0 14 43.01 4

[Dogs]

What a great even competition we have.. =D>

NRL 9 teams can win the Premiership.
W L D B PD Pts
1 Storm 12 5 0 2 161 28
2 Bulldogs 12 5 0 2 148 28
3 Broncos 11 6 0 2 86 26
4 Sharks 10 6 1 2 21 25
5 Cowboys 10 7 0 2 83 24
6 Rabbitohs 10 6 0 2 53 24
7 Sea Eagles 10 7 0 2 41 24
8 Tigers 9 8 0 2 4 22
9 Warriors 8 9 0 2 30 20
10 Dragons 8 9 0 2 -36 20
11 Titans 7 10 0 2 -26 18
12 Knights 7 10 0 2 -39 18
13 Raiders 7 10 0 2 -71 18
14 Roosters 6 9 1 2 -120 17
15 Panthers 4 13 0 2 -138 12
16 Eels 3 14 0 2 -197 10

Now compare that to this basketcase...

AFL 6 teams can win the Flag. 3 VFL sides on the bottom and no mans land from position 8 to 12.....
P W D L % Pts
1 Sydney 15 12 0 3 148.05 48
2 Adelaide 15 12 0 3 131.87 48
3 Collingwood 15 12 0 3 121.56 48
4 Hawthorn 15 11 0 4 157.00 44
5 West Coast 15 11 0 4 131.52 44
6 Essendon 15 11 0 4 130.00 44
7 Geelong 15 9 0 6 109.43 36
8 St Kilda 15 8 0 7 120.76 32
9 North Melbourne 15 8 0 7 107.97 32
10 Fremantle 15 8 0 7 97.60 32
11 Richmond 15 7 0 8 107.02 28
12 Carlton 15 7 0 8 103.72 28
13 Brisbane 15 6 0 9 92.42 24
14 Bulldogs 15 5 0 10 74.68 20
15 Port Adelaide 15 4 0 11 79.92 16
16 Melbourne 15 2 0 13 64.12 8
17 Gold Coast 15 1 0 14 57.84 4
18 Greater Western Sydney 15 1 0 14 43.01 4

More to the point eelofwest
The weekend results speaks for themselves:
- Cowboys now 5th after beat 1st place Storm
- 12th placed Knights convincing win over Manly, if knights lost they would 3rd last, Manly win, they would be equal 3rd
- 10th placed St G beat Sharks who now drop to 5th
- 6th place Rabbits beat 14th placed roosters but only in the last 2 mins and requiring two tries in 2 mins to win
- Close game between 8th placed tiger and second last Penrith
- Broncos by 2 against Warriors at home
- Only real run away, but the equal first side and form side of the comp, play last placed team, Parra in the game for nearly 3/4 of the game
- Two try win for Titans over Canberra in Canberra

Compare that to AFL round 16 results where 7 out of 9 games had a gap of more then 30 points and 5 of those where 50 or more points gap. 1 even by greater then 100 points.

[piesman2011]

Eel,
In the AFL the 9th placed Nth Melbourne are in some good form beating just about all before them over the last few weeks. The 7th place Cats could do anything and beat anyone with a little form. You could say that any of the top 9 at the moment could win the AFL flag as well. If you look at the NRL ladders the 9th placed warriors are 4 wins behind first place with the top 2 on the same points. If you look at the AFL ladder the 9th placed Nth Melbourne are 4 wins behind 1st place with the top 3 all on the same points. If anything the AFL ladder is closer together with the same amount of rounds of the season to go. However overall no real difference.

[eelofwest]

Eel,
In the AFL the 9th placed Nth Melbourne are in some good form beating just about all before them over the last few weeks. The 7th place Cats could do anything and beat anyone with a little form. You could say that any of the top 9 at the moment could win the AFL flag as well. If you look at the NRL ladders the 9th placed warriors are 4 wins behind first place with the top 2 on the same points. If you look at the AFL ladder the 9th placed Nth Melbourne are 4 wins behind 1st place with the top 3 all on the same points. If anything the AFL ladder is closer together with the same amount of rounds of the season to go. However overall no real difference.

There are 3 sides in the AFL that make Parramatta Eels look like world beaters...... Yes no real difference i see what your saying there Pies.... :D

[King-Eliagh]

if only the NRL was similar to the AFL comp eels. Then we'd have plenty more to celebrate this year. Actually if we had three deadbeat basketcase teams in our league i'd say parra would still be in with a chance at making the 8!

[eelofwest]

if only the NRL was similar to the AFL comp eels. Then we'd have plenty more to celebrate this year. Actually if we had three deadbeat basketcase teams in our league i'd say parra would still be in with a chance at making the 8!

We would no doubt be a chance of the 8 with teams like GWS, SUNS, Demons.....even chuck in PORT ADE. ..

[King-Eliagh]

WEstern bulldogs are in the same boat eels. No wonder its close up the top of the AFL comp this year. Every team has atleast 8 odd guaranteed wins!

And the AFL clan in here all believe its just amazing how close their top 8 teams are they dont think much do they?

[TLPG]

Stop comparing apples to oranges you idiots. If Parramatta went onto an AFL field, even the Campbelltown Monarchs would thrash them, let alone any of the sides you mentioned!

Needed to be said.