BS file claim#1: Earth = RL heartland

[NSWAFL]

Laugh it up, loser! You've been done like a dinner and you can't hack it!

[Beaussie]

Oh dear, seriously KE, just admit you looked stupid with this BS claim. You lose, no doubt about it.

What a silly thing to say on your part.

Earth = Rugby League Heartland. From England to Australia, France to Papua New Guinea and throughout the pacific Islands this great game is played and enjoyed by millions on this lovely planet.

OMG, this would have to be the dumbest thing you've ever said. Seriously.

[NSWAFL]

It proves me right. King is mentally ill.

[King-Eliagh]

Oh dear, seriously KE, just admit you looked stupid with this BS claim. You lose, no doubt about it.

What a silly thing to say on your part.

Earth = Rugby League Heartland. From England to Australia, France to Papua New Guinea and throughout the pacific Islands this great game is played and enjoyed by millions on this lovely planet.

OMG, this would have to be the dumbest thing you've ever said. Seriously.

Oh really Beaussie? If its so dumb hows about you do more than sound like the female teenage ditzy character in a lamo American sitcom and have a go at proving me wrong? OMG like, seriously, I want you to try that!

[King-Eliagh]

heartland [ˈhɑːtˌlænd]
n
1. (Government, Politics & Diplomacy) the central region of a country or continent
2. the core or most vital area
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/heartland

For the Earth to be RL heartland RL must be "core or most vital" to the earth. How is this ever possible if RL is a minor sport at best in the major countries of the earth such as the USA, India, China etc etc....

I call.................BS!!!!!

"The claim will be deemed "BS" if conclusively shown to be wrong" - BS file principle

So far, apart from gauging the truth of my statement by asking the goons over at LU, the only argument Xman has put forward is the topsy turvey argument above where he indicated RL rather than the Earth was Heartland This was the first ever post in the BS files and I'm ecstatic at how easy he made it for me to point and laugh

So lets get back to the lesson. As the dictionary describes Heartland is "the core or most vital area". My claim Earth = Rugby League Heartland is clearly fact as you cannot say the Earth is not the core or most vital area for Rugby League. They dont play it on the moon you know Xman

I've had great fun in here, but I'm happy for this one to be finished a few days early Xman, you're dusted now gimme my bestest and smartest point

[King-Eliagh]

Yoohoo Xman, I know you're lurking there. Cat got your tongue?

[Beaussie]

Give it up already KE. You just make yourself look stupid with each and every post now trying to defend the indefensible ridiculous claim you made. You lose. Accept the result and move on.

[King-Eliagh]

This no prove me wrong Beaussie

[Xman]

This no prove me wrong Beaussie

You're not winning a point for deliberate deception. The BS files weren't created for that. You know the exact context of the word 'heartland', and your claim isn't it.

The only way you can redeem yourself and earn a point is to start a thread on LU and ask the good folk there: "Is the earth AFL heartland". If the majority answer in the positive you can have your point. Otherwise you've failed like every person on here knows you have.

[King-Eliagh]

This no prove me wrong Beaussie

You're not winning a point for deliberate deception. The BS files weren't created for that. You know the exact context of the word 'heartland', and your claim isn't it.

The only way you can redeem yourself and earn a point is to start a thread on LU and ask the good folk there: "Is the earth AFL heartland". If the majority answer in the positive you can have your point. Otherwise you've failed like every person on here knows you have.

Don't try feeding me BS Xman! It might be your bread and butter but I won't swallow it! Parraeels didnt think I'd failed.

I meant it how I said I meant it, the Earth is a vital and core area to the game of RL. The game of RL is played on thousands of locations on this wonderful planet. The dictionary supports my argument and you still want to rely on the goons over at LU to fight your argument for you. Clear evidence Xman has lost and cannot fight/win this battle on his own. Poor and wierd form Xman. You really do have an infatuation with those boys dont you?

You've clearly got no argument Xman, nothing to disprove my claim. But you do have the mod badge and the authority to rule on who wins and who loses now dont you?

I knew the result of this thread was a foregone conclusion before you even put it up, but I think we both know you were unable to prove diddly squat. Its been entertaining making a mockery out of your case Xman, especially your inept utility of the dictionary definition.

[King-Eliagh]

OK, here's a big tip for all you keen BS file players!

Do not challenge a claim that could have multiple meanings until you know the context of the claim!

All the claimant has to do is prove their interpretation of the claim to win! The fact the challenger has a different interpretation of the claim, or that the claim could have more than one meaning is irrelevant. This may not be the interpretation that was used when the claim was made!

I would suggest in cases such as these the potential challenger asks for clarification of the meaning of the claim before challenging it.


Well I hope this handy tip has helped all you BS file players out there! Happy playing! :D

Great sound advice there Xman!

Now where were we...? Ah yes that's right. The Earth = Rugby League Heartland! :D

Bestest and smartest point Xman, you gimme one of those.

[King-Eliagh]

You never took the time to ask me to clarify the meaning of my use of the term before making your claim did you Xman

Ah well, out of failure there's always lessons to be learnt eh?

Run along now ya silly rascal :D

[cos789]

Give it up already KE. You just make yourself look stupid with each and every post now trying to defend the indefensible ridiculous claim you made. You lose. Accept the result and move on.

Actually this remark is so dumb and lame I'm surprised anyone got excited enough to promote it to the bs file
but since it here , let's close it and move on because there is no conceiveble way this isn't a loss to rl.

[King-Eliagh]

I'm surprised anyone got excited enough to promote it to the bs file

Thanks cos, I agree. I couldn't believe how foolish Xman was in thinking he could actually prove this claim to be false. There was never going to be a way and he's been made to pay for it. What a silly rascal that man is eh.

And what about the way he's contradicted his own BS file tips which I quoted above cos? Were you surprised about that too? I certainly was!

[NSWAFL]

Let's make this clear, again for the benefit for the brain-impaired King.

He said (multiple times) Earth = RL heartland. This means to every Tom, Dick and Harry that he is clearly saying that the entire Earth is rugby league heartland. Now we all know on this forum that when someone says "RL heartland" or even "AFL heartland" we are talking about an area where that sport is dominant. There is no doubt for example that New South Wales is RL heartland. There is no doubt that Victoria is AFL heartland.

With me so far?

GOOD!

Because King has made a complete arse of himself by claiming that EARTH is RL heartland! The whole planet!

Now because he has failed to prove that RL dominates the sporting fields of every country in the world, this is an instant loss for him.