Talking Footy

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

Raiderdave wrote:

it gets a following because Victorians are dunces & easily duped .... easily fooled.
if 200K people in the Nthn States ... both on pay & FTA bothered to watch this sham of a game on TV last year .... I'd be surprised
for unlike the dopes south of the border .... they have respect for our ANZACS =D> =D> =D>

& now ...with the Sydney NRL game being on FTA from now on... I'd expect it to get 1.5 Million veiwers on FTA nationally
maybe more

& of course .... 1.8 Million watch our ANZAC test nationally each year
our ANZAC matches >>>>>> the VFL's AAC ... pale imitation.

but but but

AFls ANZAC day game beats every NRL home and away game by a massive margin. AFL respect ANZAC day. RL fans

the VFL doesn't have an ANZAC game ..... it has a sham if thats what you're talking about ?

& anyway
our actual.. real.... most bona fide ANZAC game ... our Test against the kiwis .. attracted 1.8 Million
bigger then anything the VFL can muster up

Xman wrote:

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

but but but

AFls ANZAC day game beats every NRL home and away game by a massive margin. AFL respect ANZAC day. RL fans

the VFL doesn't have an ANZAC game ..... it has a sham if thats what you're talking about ?

& anyway
our actual.. real.... most bona fide ANZAC game ... our Test against the kiwis .. attracted 1.8 Million
bigger then anything the VFL can muster up

Wow, how many people at this game? 80, 90k?



AFLs ANZAC day game is a massive event where players and fans turnout in huge numbers to pay respect to the ANZACS.

ARL, NRL......amateur hour..

Xman wrote:

Whether the AFLs ANZAC day is authentic is an opinion and irrelevant given its an attitude. Fans and players turnout to pay respect the the ANZACS. War heroes are invited and parade. A minutes silence is held. Many official ceremonies are included.

The fans turnout in massive numbers and believe they are paying respect. That's what matters.

Not some false impression including a few players from NZ makes the difference. It doesn't, especially when few fans turn out.

Including NZ is irrelevant. They have their own ceremonies many of which don't include Australia. What's important is that the ANZACs are remembered and honoured. And the AFL do an amazing job with a huge response. The NRL and their fans clearly aren't that interested.

Xman wrote:

Wrong. There is nothing written to say that ANY event needs members from both countries to be considered an ANZAC day event. Unless of course you have evidence to the contrary. However I've asked for this before and youve failed like the Dave you are.

All an ANZAC day event needs is people who are prepared to remember and honour the ANZACs. Having some of the ANZAC day veterans also helps. The AFL have both in significant numbers. =D>

Shame the NRLs attempts a ignored by most, even their own fans. Seems like adding NZ players adds little to the authenticity of the event. Otherwise fans may actually turnout.

Xman wrote:

Where does it say NZ must be included in a ceremony or event?

Simple question Dave. Got an answer?

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

Where does it say NZ must be included in a ceremony or event?

Simple question Dave. Got an answer?

even the VFL now recognises the need for NZ on April 25th
they are essentially agreeing with me

you on the other hand .... continue to be a lil vicky kicky cheerleader

oh we don't need anyone else


ask vlad why hes rushing accross the tasman then c head

Xman wrote:

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

Where does it say NZ must be included in a ceremony or event?

Simple question Dave. Got an answer?

even the VFL now recognises the need for NZ on April 25th
they are essentially agreeing with me

you on the other hand .... continue to be a lil vicky kicky cheerleader

oh we don't need anyone else


ask vlad why hes rushing accross the tasman then c head

The fact the AFL are playing a game in NZ has no bearing on the authenticity of an ANZAC day event without both countries involved.

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

Raiderdave wrote:

even the VFL now recognises the need for NZ on April 25th
they are essentially agreeing with me

you on the other hand .... continue to be a lil vicky kicky cheerleader

oh we don't need anyone else


ask vlad why hes rushing accross the tasman then c head

The fact the AFL are playing a game in NZ has no bearing on the authenticity of an ANZAC day event without both countries involved.

sure it doesn't .... sure

Xman wrote:

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

The fact the AFL are playing a game in NZ has no bearing on the authenticity of an ANZAC day event without both countries involved.

sure it doesn't .... sure

any evidence showing an Anzac Day event must, have both countries involved?

Raiderdave wrote:

Xman wrote:

Raiderdave wrote:

sure it doesn't .... sure

any evidence showing an Anzac Day event must, have both countries involved?

evidence

the VFL ... rushing ova to NZ mainly because they didn't have any NZ involvment on April 25th & they now know this is essential
to be even half authentic

yep... all the evidence right there

During the 1920s ANZAC Day became established as a national day of commemoration for the 60,000 Australians who had died during the war. In 1927, for the first time every state observed some form of public holiday on ANZAC Day. By the mid-1930s, all the rituals we now associate with the day – dawn vigils, marches, memorial services, reunions, two-up games – were firmly established as part of ANZAC Day culture.

With the coming of the Second World War, ANZAC Day also served to commemorate the lives of Australians who died in that war. In subsequent years the meaning of the day has been further broadened to include Australians killed in all the military operations in which Australia has been involved.

ANZAC Day was first commemorated at the Memorial in 1942. There were government orders prohibiting large public gatherings in case of a Japanese air attack, so it was a small occasion, with neither a march nor a memorial service. Since then, ANZAC Day has been commemorated at the Memorial every year.