Talking Footy

NSWAFL wrote:

Let's make this clear, again for the benefit for the brain-impaired King.

He said (multiple times) Earth = RL heartland. This means to every Tom, Dick and Harry that he is clearly saying that the entire Earth is rugby league heartland. Now we all know on this forum that when someone says "RL heartland" or even "AFL heartland" we are talking about an area where that sport is dominant. There is no doubt for example that New South Wales is RL heartland. There is no doubt that Victoria is AFL heartland.

With me so far?

GOOD!

Because King has made a complete arse of himself by claiming that EARTH is RL heartland! The whole planet!

Now because he has failed to prove that RL dominates the sporting fields of every country in the world, this is an instant loss for him.

King-Eliagh the bestest and smartest wrote:

Earth being RL Heartland? It’s a fact…Truth is you cant prove its not as RL is played on Earth right?

King-Eliagh wrote:

Xman wrote:

OK, here's a big tip for all you keen BS file players!

Do not challenge a claim that could have multiple meanings until you know the context of the claim!

All the claimant has to do is prove their interpretation of the claim to win! The fact the challenger has a different interpretation of the claim, or that the claim could have more than one meaning is irrelevant. This may not be the interpretation that was used when the claim was made!

I would suggest in cases such as these the potential challenger asks for clarification of the meaning of the claim before challenging it.


Well I hope this handy tip has helped all you BS file players out there! Happy playing! :D

Great sound advice there Xman!

Now where were we...? Ah yes that's right. The Earth = Rugby League Heartland! :D

Bestest and smartest point Xman, you gimme one of those.

King-Eliagh wrote:

So I have no right to express the word in the literally correct context on these boards? "Bizarre interpretation" indeed! Hmmph you really are some contradictory dictator moderator now arent you!

And secondly I didnt put this file up, you did you silly turkey, you're the one who's "wasted all our time" putting up a BS file that was impossible to disprove. You make me sick, you and your lil puffed up bimbo sidekick nswafl.

King-Eliagh wrote:

I didnt think you'd be so gullible to take that dare literally. I mean I gave you the context and all, illustrating you could not win before you started it. It has been amusing though Xman, thanks for that.

Now garnish me with bestest and smartest point.

King-Eliagh the bestest and smartest wrote:

Earth being RL Heartland? It’s a fact…Truth is you cant prove its not as RL is played on Earth right?

King-Eliagh wrote:

King-Eliagh the bestest and smartest wrote:

Earth being RL Heartland? It’s a fact…Truth is you cant prove its not as RL is played on Earth right?

There's your warning of the context in which I was using it buster.

I didnt deliberately deceive you. I was as transparent as could be, as per usual.

Now put the sugar on top of my glorious win and gimme bestest and smartest points

King-Eliagh wrote:

You've already made that pithy argument. You need to go back to the dictionary definition you chose and reconsider your argument.

You cant shoot me for using the literally correct meaning of a word. OR can you? I've seen dictatorial aussie rules mods do worse

Xman wrote:

As is said the vast majority of sports fans would have shot your claim down as Bs.

Do not challenge a claim that could have multiple meanings until you know the context of the claim!

All the claimant has to do is prove their interpretation of the claim to win! The fact the challenger has a different interpretation of the claim, or that the claim could have more than one meaning is irrelevant. This may not be the interpretation that was used when the claim was made!

Xman wrote:

Therefore you deliberately attempted to deceive to gain a point

That's not the purpose of the Bs file. It's for challenging BS, not cheating.

King-Eliagh wrote:

Xman wrote:

As is said the vast majority of sports fans would have shot your claim down as Bs.

This isnt about the majority of sports fans, its about whether we have the freedom to use a word with its literally correct meaning. Earth = Rugby LEague Heartland and there's simply no way to disprove this, its fundamentally correct.

Do not challenge a claim that could have multiple meanings until you know the context of the claim!

All the claimant has to do is prove their interpretation of the claim to win! The fact the challenger has a different interpretation of the claim, or that the claim could have more than one meaning is irrelevant. This may not be the interpretation that was used when the claim was made!

Yeah thats better, why dont you say this stuff some more

Xman wrote:

Therefore you deliberately attempted to deceive to gain a point

That's not the purpose of the Bs file. It's for challenging BS, not cheating.

I didnt want this claim to go forward. You sought it out and made the claim you knobbly kneed fat assed goat! You're the 'challenger' or have you been so bamboozled you've forgotten whether you're arthur or marthur? That first post is evidence you were a lost cause in this thread from the get go.

Earth = Rugby LEague Heartland Xman, prove it isnt or gimme my bestest and smartest gimme it

NSWAFL wrote:

You can't allow a stalemate, Xman?? We all know that King's context is fake. He made the statement and we all know what it means. He's too dumb to recognise when he's been got good.