Talking Footy

Xman wrote:

eelofwest wrote:

Can you see blind freddy how lopsided your competition is....

it will resolve in the coming season and we will end up with a healthy comp that has at least 2 teams in the biggest 5 states in Australia, and 9 teams or 50% outside the main city in Melbourne.

Where as the NRL is limping along with teams in only 3 states and the vast majority of their teams in the one city.

I know which position id rather be in thats for sure.

Wait 3 states......

NRL 2 countries. NZ AUS
NRL 4 states. QLD, NSW, WA soon, Auckland. population total = approximately 19million
AFL 4 states, with a pop cap of about 9million at best...

Please Xman spare everyone your NRL 2 state propaganda.....

eelofwest wrote:

Xman wrote:

eelofwest wrote:

Can you see blind freddy how lopsided your competition is....

it will resolve in the coming season and we will end up with a healthy comp that has at least 2 teams in the biggest 5 states in Australia, and 9 teams or 50% outside the main city in Melbourne.

Where as the NRL is limping along with teams in only 3 states and the vast majority of their teams in the one city.

I know which position id rather be in thats for sure.

Wait 3 states......

NRL 2 countries. NZ AUS
NRL 4 states. QLD, NSW, WA soon, Auckland. population total = approximately 19million
AFL 4 states, with a pop cap of about 9million at best...

Please Xman spare everyone your NRL 2 state propaganda.....

SO youre counting WA?

You havent even got a team there and according to the ARLC may not even have one within the next few years.

Youve got 1 team in Melbourne which is struggling. Youve got all but one Australian team in 2 states.
You play maybe 14 games a year outside NSW/ACT/QLD. The AFL play around 50 games outside its VIC/SA/WA.

Not to mention AFL games being played in Darwin, Canberra, Hobart and Cairns. And likely playing in NZ if St.Kilda get their way!

Hey lads we seem to have all forgot the NRL has a team in Canberra. Not a state I know but for these purposes I think we can count it.

King-Eliagh wrote:

Hey lads we seem to have all forgot the NRL has a team in Canberra. Not a state I know but for these purposes I think we can count it.

"Not a state" covers it. Its only hours outside Sydney.

eelofwest wrote:

TLPG wrote:

King-Eliagh wrote:

Thats greast guys. Can you point to the season or round please? I'd hate to think you're just saying you have and just joshin with us.

All seasons except for 1976 during the time of zoning. I don't have time to go through them one by one.

This is what the NRL ladder looks like if it were 4 points for a win as in the AFL.

NRL Round 21

W L D B PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 14 5 0 2 170 64
2 Rabbitohs 13 6 0 2 103 60
3 Storm 12 7 0 2 147 56
4 Cowboys 11 8 0 2 82 52
5 Broncos 11 8 0 2 62 52
6 Sea Eagles 11 8 0 2 35 52
7 Sharks 10 8 1 2 -12 50
8 Titans 9 10 0 2 -2 44
9 Knights 9 10 0 2 -4 44
10 Tigers 9 10 0 2 -35 44
11 Dragons 9 10 0 2 -50 44
12 Warriors 8 11 0 2 23 40
13 Raiders 8 11 0 2 -69 40
14 Roosters 6 12 1 2 -154 34
15 Panthers 6 13 0 2 -125 32
16 Eels 5wins 14 0 2 -171 28 Just smashed the 4th Spot Brisbane broncos at Suncorp... =D>

AFL

Round 18 another possible 12 points to add to those top sides...

P W D L % Pts
1 Sydney 17 14 0 3 151.31 56
2 Hawthorn 17 13 0 4 160.09 52
3 Adelaide 17 13 0 4 129.42 52
4 Collingwood 17 13 0 4 123.82 52
5 West Coast 17 12 0 5 130.49 48
6 Geelong 17 11 0 6 115.04 44
7 Essendon 17 11 0 6 113.25 44
8 North Melbourne 17 10 0 7 110.59 40
9 Fremantle 17 10 0 7 106.90 40
10 St Kilda 17 9 0 8 121.88 36
11 Carlton 17 9 0 8 104.76 36
12 Richmond 17 7 0 10 105.58 28
13 Brisbane 17 7 0 10 88.06 28
14 Port Adelaide 17 5 0 12 81.66 20
15 Bulldogs 17 5 0 12 72.34 20
16 Melbourne 17 2 0 15 63.78 8
17 Gold Coast 17 1 0 16 57.58 4
18 Greater Western Sydney 17 1 0 16 41.18 4


Now open your eyes and make a comparison.

All this and the NRL has more upsets week in week out. =D>


Update

AFL Blowouts 2012

Round 1
GWS 37 - 100 SYD, GCS 68 - 137 ADE
Round 2
BRI 63 - 154 CAR, WCE 166 - 58 MEL, NM 183 - 54 GWS, STK 139 - 47 GCS
Round 3
CAR 122 - 62 COL, RIC 133 - 74 MEL ,WBD 40 - 103 STK, GWS 69 - 150 WCE, HAW 140 - 84 ADE
Round 4
BRI 111 - 46 GCS , GWS 62 - 104 WBD
Round 6
ESS 129 - 62 BRI CAR 110 - 43 GWS
Round 7
MEL 49 - 115 HAW, ADE 122 - 72 GEE, BRI 58 - 116 COL, ESS 113 - 52 WCE,
Round 8
HAW 119 - 63 FRE, SYD 138 - 37 MEL, WBD 72 - 34 GCS, CAR 55 - 124 ADE,
BRI 132 - 40 GWS
Round 9
RIC 137 - 75 HAW, GWS 53 - 119 ESS, CAR 107 - 49 MEL,
Round 10
GEE 126 - 61 GWS, HAW 174 - 59 NM, SYD 132 - 40 WBD, COL 149 - 52 GCS
Round 11 Byes for NM, Brisbane, GWS, WCE, WBD
GCS 49 - 144 STK
Round 12 Byes for Collingwood, Sydney, Essendon, Melbourne Demons, Dockers.
HAW 135 - 70 BRI,
Round 13 Byes for Richmond, Hawthorn, Port Ade, St Kilda, Gold Coast Suns, Carlton.
WBD 56 - 114 BRI, MEL 135 - 57 GWS
Round 14
WCE 166 - 40 GCS, SYD 132 - 38 GWS, ESS 140 - 56 WBD, BRI 122 - 61 MEL
Round 15
SYD 110 - 63 BRI, STK 133 - 62 ESS, POR 58 - 116 ADE, HAW 193 - 31 GWS
Round 16
GWS 59 - 178 ADE, WBD 44 - 116 HAW
Round 17
GEE 134 - 67 ESS, FRE 132 - 37 GWS
Round 18
ESS 86 - 180 HAW, GWS 54 - 174 COL, GCS 54 - 126 SYD, STK 118 - 42 WBD, WCE 175 - 77 BRI Wow 5 games were dead set floggings in 1 round of AFL..

13 Brisbane 17 7 0 10 88.06 28
14 Port Adelaide 17 5 0 12 81.66 20
15 Bulldogs 17 5 0 12 72.34 20
16 Melbourne 17 2 0 15 63.78 8
17 Gold Coast 17 1 0 16 57.58 4
18 Greater Western Sydney 17 1 0 16 41.18 4

1. GWS 15 Floggings
2. GCS 9 Floggings
3. Mel 6 Floggings
4. WBD 6 Floggings
5. BRI 6 Floggings


5 Floggings in Round 18, until you show us some proof/substance that this has happened before your word means nothing.

Upadate 17/08/12 Round 23 What the NRL table looks like if using the AFL point system.

W L D B PD Pts
1 Bulldogs 16 5 0 2 194 72
2 Storm 14 7 0 2 195 64
3 Rabbitohs 14 7 0 2 90 64
4 Sea Eagles 13 8 0 2 54 60
5 Cowboys 12 9 0 2 120 56
6 Sharks 11 9 1 2 7 54
7 Broncos 11 10 0 2 38 52
8 Tigers 11 10 0 2 0 52
9 Knights 10 11 0 2 2 48
10 Raiders 10 11 0 2 -43 48
11 Titans 9 12 0 2 -14 44
12 Dragons 9 12 0 2 -76 44
13 Warriors 8 13 0 2 -58 40
14 Roosters 7 13 1 2 -152 38
15 Panthers 6 15 0 2 -175 32
16 Eels 6 15 0 2 -182 32


Round 20 add a possible 12 points to these teams...

P W D L % Pts
1 Sydney 19 15 0 4 146.62 60
2 Adelaide 19 15 0 4 127.90 60
3 Collingwood 19 15 0 4 122.34 60
4 Hawthorn 19 14 0 5 156.55 56
5 West Coast 19 13 0 6 122.76 52
6 North Melbourne 19 12 0 7 114.07 48
7 Geelong 19 12 0 7 112.88 48
8 Essendon 19 11 0 8 110.07 44
9 Fremantle 19 11 0 8 108.60 44
10 St Kilda 19 10 0 9 120.74 40
11 Carlton 19 10 0 9 105.12 40
12 Richmond 19 9 0 10 112.04 36
13 Brisbane 19 7 0 12 85.11 28
14 Port Adelaide 19 5 0 14 78.54 20
15 Bulldogs 19 5 0 14 69.67 20
16 Melbourne 19 3 0 16 67.70 12
17 Gold Coast 19 2 0 17 60.77 8
18 Greater Western Sydney 19 2 0 17 45.81 8

AFL the most lopsided competition i have seen.

AFL Blowouts 2012

Round 1
GWS 37 - 100 SYD, GCS 68 - 137 ADE
Round 2
BRI 63 - 154 CAR, WCE 166 - 58 MEL, NM 183 - 54 GWS, STK 139 - 47 GCS
Round 3
CAR 122 - 62 COL, RIC 133 - 74 MEL ,WBD 40 - 103 STK, GWS 69 - 150 WCE, HAW 140 - 84 ADE
Round 4
BRI 111 - 46 GCS , GWS 62 - 104 WBD
Round 6
ESS 129 - 62 BRI CAR 110 - 43 GWS
Round 7
MEL 49 - 115 HAW, ADE 122 - 72 GEE, BRI 58 - 116 COL, ESS 113 - 52 WCE,
Round 8
HAW 119 - 63 FRE, SYD 138 - 37 MEL, WBD 72 - 34 GCS, CAR 55 - 124 ADE,
BRI 132 - 40 GWS
Round 9
RIC 137 - 75 HAW, GWS 53 - 119 ESS, CAR 107 - 49 MEL,
Round 10
GEE 126 - 61 GWS, HAW 174 - 59 NM, SYD 132 - 40 WBD, COL 149 - 52 GCS
Round 11 Byes for NM, Brisbane, GWS, WCE, WBD
GCS 49 - 144 STK
Round 12 Byes for Collingwood, Sydney, Essendon, Melbourne Demons, Dockers.
HAW 135 - 70 BRI,
Round 13 Byes for Richmond, Hawthorn, Port Ade, St Kilda, Gold Coast Suns, Carlton.
WBD 56 - 114 BRI, MEL 135 - 57 GWS
Round 14
WCE 166 - 40 GCS, SYD 132 - 38 GWS, ESS 140 - 56 WBD, BRI 122 - 61 MEL
Round 15
SYD 110 - 63 BRI, STK 133 - 62 ESS, POR 58 - 116 ADE, HAW 193 - 31 GWS
Round 16
GWS 59 - 178 ADE, WBD 44 - 116 HAW
Round 17
GEE 134 - 67 ESS, FRE 132 - 37 GWS
Round 18
ESS 86 - 180 HAW, GWS 54 - 174 COL, GCS 54 - 126 SYD, STK 118 - 42 WBD, WCE 175 - 77 BRI Wow 5 games were dead set floggings in 1 round of AFL..
Round 19 OMG NO FLOGGINGS, THIS HAS TO BE A FIRST....
Round 20
RIC 150 - 80 WBD, HAW 159 - 87 POR

The VFL
13 Brisbane 19 7 0 12 85.11 28
14 Port Adelaide 19 5 0 14 78.54 20
15 Bulldogs 19 5 0 14 69.67 20
16 Melbourne 19 3 0 16 67.70 12
17 Gold Coast 19 2 0 17 60.77 8
18 Greater Western Sydney 19 2 0 17 45.81 8

1. GWS 15 Floggings
2. GCS 9 Floggings
3. WBD 7 Floggings
4. Mel 6 Floggings
5. BRI 6 Floggings

Xman every time you have nothing to say you take the thread of topic. You are terrible and week...

Wow its a closely fought battle for the top three in the VFL this year. Probably the closest tussle I've ever seen

King-Eliagh wrote:

Wow its a closely fought battle for the top three in the VFL this year. Probably the closest tussle I've ever seen

I think GWS and GCS have done well in the VFL this year... they will be champs of the VFL soon....

eelofwest wrote:

King-Eliagh wrote:

Wow its a closely fought battle for the top three in the VFL this year. Probably the closest tussle I've ever seen

I think GWS and GCS have done well in the VFL this year... they will be champs of the VFL soon....

Funny how 44% of AFL clubs are outside of Victoria but only 33% of the NRL clubs are outside NSW yet you continue to use the "VFL" comment.

Eel I notice that you didn't correct the NRL ladder to align with the AFL points system.

So who's avoiding the topic again?

Xman wrote:

eelofwest wrote:

King-Eliagh wrote:

Wow its a closely fought battle for the top three in the VFL this year. Probably the closest tussle I've ever seen

I think GWS and GCS have done well in the VFL this year... they will be champs of the VFL soon....

Funny how 44% of AFL clubs are outside of Victoria but only 33% of the NRL clubs are outside NSW yet you continue to use the "VFL" comment.

Yes thank you for pointing out that all your expansion teams in the last 30 years are in the VFL.......

The Expansion disaster...

13 Brisbane 19 7 0 12 85.11 28
14 Port Adelaide 19 5 0 14 78.54 20
15 Bulldogs 19 5 0 14 69.67 20
16 Melbourne 19 3 0 16 67.70 12
17 Gold Coast 19 2 0 17 60.77 8
18 Greater Western Sydney 19 2 0 17 45.81 8

Thank you for validating our thought's that this is the most lopsided AFL in recent memory.

eelofwest wrote:

Xman wrote:

eelofwest wrote:

I think GWS and GCS have done well in the VFL this year... they will be champs of the VFL soon....

Funny how 44% of AFL clubs are outside of Victoria but only 33% of the NRL clubs are outside NSW yet you continue to use the "VFL" comment.

Yes thank you for pointing out that all your expansion teams in the last 30 years are in the VFL.......

The Expansion disaster...

13 Brisbane 19 7 0 12 85.11 28
14 Port Adelaide 19 5 0 14 78.54 20
15 Bulldogs 19 5 0 14 69.67 20
16 Melbourne 19 3 0 16 67.70 12
17 Gold Coast 19 2 0 17 60.77 8
18 Greater Western Sydney 19 2 0 17 45.81 8

Thank you for validating our thought's that this is the most lopsided AFL in recent memory.

what a fool. of the 8 teams outside Victoria 2 are in the top 4, another will probably make the 8, two others won a premiership within the last decade and are experiencing the typical rise and fall, and two are brand new.

Try 2001, Eel/idiot!

Top side Essendon 68 points (and didn't win the flag!)
Bottom side Fremantle 8 points

And 2000?

Top side Essendon 84 points
Bottom side St.Kilda 10 points

Living memory huh?

Xman wrote:

eelofwest wrote:

Xman wrote:

Funny how 44% of AFL clubs are outside of Victoria but only 33% of the NRL clubs are outside NSW yet you continue to use the "VFL" comment.

Yes thank you for pointing out that all your expansion teams in the last 30 years are in the VFL.......

The Expansion disaster...

13 Brisbane 19 7 0 12 85.11 28
14 Port Adelaide 19 5 0 14 78.54 20
15 Bulldogs 19 5 0 14 69.67 20
16 Melbourne 19 3 0 16 67.70 12
17 Gold Coast 19 2 0 17 60.77 8
18 Greater Western Sydney 19 2 0 17 45.81 8

Thank you for validating our thought's that this is the most lopsided AFL in recent memory.

what a fool. of the 8 teams outside Victoria 2 are in the top 4, another will probably make the 8, two others won a premiership within the last decade and are experiencing the typical rise and fall, and two are brand new.

Oh how i love getting under your skin Xman.........

And meanwhile, Eel, you try to ignore my points like the coward you are. You haven't got under Xman's skin. How can you with such ignorance?