TLPG wrote:Cracker wrote:TLPG wrote:Cracker wrote:Indeed, Miss Penny. The AFL did have something like it, and let it go.
*applies the brakes*
Oh no you don't, Cracker! I'm not letting that one slide! The AFL didn't just "let it go". The clubs scotched it as I remember, and there were several reasons. For one thing, promoting Victoria v SA would have left WA out in the cold and they made it clear they wanted in on it. A three way on the back of the abject failure of the Allies just wasn't practical. For another, club representation has now pretty much wrecked interest, in that every mainland state is represented. That issue doesn't affect the NRL so much because all the clubs bar Melbourne and New Zealand (and technically Canberra) are in two states. Finally, AFL State of Origin rode on the back of one man - Ted Whitten Snr. When he passed away the enthusiasm for state rivalry finally died combined with the other two reasons.
So it's not a case of the AFL "let it go". The fact is we don't need it anymore. Swans came up with an idea that might work, but really the interest just won't be there to get it off the ground. The AFL is club orientated and that's a contributing factor in my opinion to the AFL's much higher crowd average.
I think the AFL do need it, but the club factor is relevant. Even in the NRL there are rumblings along those lines due to injuries. But the sheer weight of the event overcomes that. It's as big as the NRL grand final if not even bigger, especially with the biggest hook of the lot - can New South Wales finally top Queensland this year? Back when it was played you could have said the same thing for South Australia against Victoria. Could they top them, especially in Melbourne? I can't believe that was on the back of the late great EJ Whitten only. He only wanted Victoria to win. It took the passion of SA to overcome that, heading up by someone who was just as important - Neil Kerley. This could have been maintained as a legacy. One could put a case that the equally great late Artie Beetson carries a similar legacy from the beginnings of the rugby league version, even though there have been many others.
It is a great money spinner, TLPG, and a ratings king as Raiderdave rightly pointed out.
When it comes to money spinners during the home and away season, ANZAC Day Collingwood v Essendon holds it's own. The crowds at a lot of the MCG games are huge, with many of them outdrawing thugby league State of Origin purely because the MCG holds more people than the Olympic Stadium. The only time club thugby league games go even close is during the finals and even then it's usually only grand final day.
Sorry - I'll take club games in the AFL over AFL State of Origin any day of the week.

:_<> :_<> :_<>
the ANZAC haters game at the MCG would have an average ticket price of about $10 ( with the kiddies getting in for $2)
so a gate of approx. $900,000 to a million bucks
this years state of Origin has an average ticket price of about $200 the most expensive tickets going for about $400
so game 1 will have a gate of over $10 million dollars
game 2
about 16 million dollars & game 3 another 10 million
the disrespectful ANZAC haters game is not in the same postcode as Origin
not even close
wow
how fucking dumb are these fumblers

:_<> :_<> :_<> :_<> :_<>
RL SOO II 4.194 Million veiwers
RL SOO I 4.068 Million
NRL GF 3.968 Million
VFL Grand Final 3.620 Million
SOO III 3.364 Million
NRL Prelim 2.219 Million
Kangaroos V NZ 1.214 Million
Sookerwhos V Japan 238K
