Talking Footy

As i said the sun shines out of a skunks ass somedays xman.

So if they win twice they're competitive?

Not really but hey you gotta draw the line somewhere.

King-Eliagh wrote:

No freo are in the middle division. You were the one who initially suggested freo were uncompetitive.

Its just melb brissy gws and gc for now xman. Although there's several sides that seem to be vying for a spot in the basketcase league.

So this is the different leagues in the AFL

Elite devision
1 West Coast 3 3 0 0 211.21 12
2 Carlton 3 3 0 0 194.66 12
3 Sydney 3 3 0 0 148.76 12
4 Essendon 3 3 0 0 115.94 12

Middle league
5 St Kilda 3 2 0 1 185.80 8
6 North Melbourne 3 2 0 1 152.94 8
7 Hawthorn 3 2 0 1 126.12 8
8 Adelaide 3 2 0 1 111.40 8
9 Fremantle 3 2 0 1 108.70 8
10 Richmond 3 1 0 2 97.89 4
11 Geelong 3 1 0 2 94.17 4
12 Port Adelaide 3 1 0 2 85.71 4
13 Collingwood 3 1 0 2 81.11 4

Lower League
14 Brisbane 3 1 0 2 73.31 4

Basketcase League
15 Bulldogs 3 0 0 3 59.50 0
16 Gold Coast 3 0 0 3 53.28 0
17 Melbourne 3 0 0 3 50.24 0
18 Greater Western Sydney 3 0 0 3 36.95 0

eelofwest wrote:

King-Eliagh wrote:

No freo are in the middle division. You were the one who initially suggested freo were uncompetitive.

Its just melb brissy gws and gc for now xman. Although there's several sides that seem to be vying for a spot in the basketcase league.

So this is the different leagues in the AFL

Elite devision
1 West Coast 3 3 0 0 211.21 12
2 Carlton 3 3 0 0 194.66 12
3 Sydney 3 3 0 0 148.76 12
4 Essendon 3 3 0 0 115.94 12

Middle league
5 St Kilda 3 2 0 1 185.80 8
6 North Melbourne 3 2 0 1 152.94 8
7 Hawthorn 3 2 0 1 126.12 8
8 Adelaide 3 2 0 1 111.40 8
9 Fremantle 3 2 0 1 108.70 8
10 Richmond 3 1 0 2 97.89 4
11 Geelong 3 1 0 2 94.17 4
12 Port Adelaide 3 1 0 2 85.71 4
13 Collingwood 3 1 0 2 81.11 4

Lower League
14 Brisbane 3 1 0 2 73.31 4

Basketcase League
15 Bulldogs 3 0 0 3 59.50 0
16 Gold Coast 3 0 0 3 53.28 0
17 Melbourne 3 0 0 3 50.24 0
18 Greater Western Sydney 3 0 0 3 36.95 0

You're seriously attempting to categories teams after 3 rounds?

Essendon are 3-0 but have played two of last years bottom teams! They'll be lucky to make the eight.

Collingwood are still elite. They've played 2 of the best teams and have many injuries. Geelong are the same, theyve played interstate and just lost, and they've beaten hawthorn.

You have NFI!

Ahh not bad eels but can i make some corrections. Brissy need to go in the basketcase league as their only win was against melbourne, another baskercaser so they belong together. Also id prob mix the elites up a bit but that's something which is hard to determine at this early stage. There will be some switching there but definitely the basketcases will not change.

Thanks for putting this up eels it looks great.

I'd do a similar thing for the NRl but in all honesty I couldn't care about the game and have no idea who is better than who!

But I'm like all other people in Victoria, SA WA and Tasmania. The NRL is irrelevant!

Yes Xman we know you know nothing about RL which is why pretty much everything you say in here has zero cred. But I care about the AFL comp which is why my concerns. Now please Xman, for the love of god give us some options to fix this lopsided comp called the AFL.

King-Eliagh wrote:

Yes Xman we know you know nothing about RL which is why pretty much everything you say in here has zero cred. But I care about the AFL comp which is why my concerns. Now please Xman, for the love of god give us some options to fix this lopsided comp called the AFL.

You care about AFL

I don't need to know who's doing well or not well in the NRL to know about the game, and how crap it is!

So are there any others out there who have tips on how the AFL could resolve this miserable lopsidedness within the next few years? I'll give it a few days and then get to writing to AFL HQ on the findings within this thread.

King-Eliagh wrote:

Ahh not bad eels but can i make some corrections. Brissy need to go in the basketcase league as their only win was against melbourne, another baskercaser so they belong together. Also id prob mix the elites up a bit but that's something which is hard to determine at this early stage. There will be some switching there but definitely the basketcases will not change.

Thanks for putting this up eels it looks great.

Okay so this looks better then,

So this is the different leagues in the AFL

Elite devision
1 West Coast 3 3 0 0 211.21 12
2 Carlton 3 3 0 0 194.66 12
3 Sydney 3 3 0 0 148.76 12
4 Essendon 3 3 0 0 115.94 12
7 Hawthorn 3 2 0 1 126.12 8

Middle league
5 St Kilda 3 2 0 1 185.80 8
6 North Melbourne 3 2 0 1 152.94 8
8 Adelaide 3 2 0 1 111.40 8
9 Fremantle 3 2 0 1 108.70 8
10 Richmond 3 1 0 2 97.89 4
11 Geelong 3 1 0 2 94.17 4
12 Port Adelaide 3 1 0 2 85.71 4
13 Collingwood 3 1 0 2 81.11 4

Basketcase League
14 Brisbane 3 1 0 2 73.31 4
15 Bulldogs 3 0 0 3 59.50 0
16 Gold Coast 3 0 0 3 53.28 0
17 Melbourne 3 0 0 3 50.24 0
18 Greater Western Sydney 3 0 0 3 36.95 0

King-Eliagh wrote:

So are there any others out there who have tips on how the AFL could resolve this miserable lopsidedness within the next few years? I'll give it a few days and then get to writing to AFL HQ on the findings within this thread.

The nature of the concessions and draft will even the comp out in the next 3-4 years. This was always the plan.

eelofwest wrote:

King-Eliagh wrote:

Ahh not bad eels but can i make some corrections. Brissy need to go in the basketcase league as their only win was against melbourne, another baskercaser so they belong together. Also id prob mix the elites up a bit but that's something which is hard to determine at this early stage. There will be some switching there but definitely the basketcases will not change.

Thanks for putting this up eels it looks great.

Okay so this looks better then,

So this is the different leagues in the AFL

Elite devision
1 West Coast 3 3 0 0 211.21 12
2 Carlton 3 3 0 0 194.66 12
3 Sydney 3 3 0 0 148.76 12
4 Essendon 3 3 0 0 115.94 12
7 Hawthorn 3 2 0 1 126.12 8

Middle league
5 St Kilda 3 2 0 1 185.80 8
6 North Melbourne 3 2 0 1 152.94 8
8 Adelaide 3 2 0 1 111.40 8
9 Fremantle 3 2 0 1 108.70 8
10 Richmond 3 1 0 2 97.89 4
11 Geelong 3 1 0 2 94.17 4
12 Port Adelaide 3 1 0 2 85.71 4
13 Collingwood 3 1 0 2 81.11 4

Basketcase League
14 Brisbane 3 1 0 2 73.31 4
15 Bulldogs 3 0 0 3 59.50 0
16 Gold Coast 3 0 0 3 53.28 0
17 Melbourne 3 0 0 3 50.24 0
18 Greater Western Sydney 3 0 0 3 36.95 0

Essendon and Sydney are not in the top!

The bulldogs are certainly not in the bottom!

Collingwood are in the top!

Xman wrote:

I'd do a similar thing for the NRl but in all honesty I couldn't care about the game and have no idea who is better than who!

But I'm like all other people in Victoria, SA WA and Tasmania. The NRL is irrelevant!

But it would be irrelevant as you have just conceded in the thread Round 2 floggings that this comment is wrong as you would be hard pressed doing the same in League,

XMAN's Said: I'll concede the NrL appears the more even comp,

Given the above responses, I am pipping you do care . Again in this thread you are now trying to use your famous deflection tactic when you are embarrassed or wrong

Okay enough!

You want lopsided? Show me the last time in the AFL that the following scoreline showed up;

Team 1 55.33 (363)
Team 2 1.1 (7)

Now THAT is lopsided! 1.92% of the winning score.

Now then - how many times have there been instances of 0% of the winning score in the NRL? And how many in the AFL?

I've said enough.....

Bye!