Just caught up on this thread and considering Truthsayers first update suggested that this thread goes off the topic, I cna say that his comments have being very interesting. Starting with his very first one.
However, lets move on. You want some figures. Wikipedia is where the regional numbers came from.
I am sure Onion or Beaussie or now even Truthsayer will suggest this is wrong regardless of what is presented. However, if you are going to do so at least try to back up your responses with some sort of evidence, that would be a refreshing change. Beaussie, no more preach GWS website and keep it to TV viewings. I also don’t want to hear the figures are flawed as they all are to an extent, but they are the best we have, so we are all on the same playing field, with the exception of ozTAM being heavily bias in terms of the number of counters who live in AFL States.
Let’s talk why regional viewers can make a real difference in the counts and why AFL fans are so forceful in trying to turn a blind eye to regional Australia. Here are some of the numbers as to why we have to recognise the small cities in each state. I have added comments as some are already in the ozTAM counts or would be split 50/50 across the codes to be fair. Below represents the numbers of people that live in each of our largest recognise regional cities in Australia:
Gold Coast-Tweed Qld/NSW 591473 Already Counted by ozTAM
Newcastle NSW 546788 Not Counted
Canberra-Queanbeyan ACT 410419 Not Counted
Wollongong NSW 292190 Not Counted
Sunshine Coast Qld 251081 Not Counted
Greater Hobart Tas 214705 Not Counted
Geelong Vic 178650 Already Counted by ozTAM
Townsville Qld 172316 Not Counted
Cairns Qld 150920 Not Counted
Toowoomba Qld 131258 Not Counted
Launceston Tas 106153 Not Counted
Ballarat Vic 96097 Not Counted
Bendigo Vic 91713 Not Counted
Mandurah WA 85814 Already Counted by ozTAM
Mackay Qld 85700 Not Counted
Burnie-Devonport Tas 82567 Not Counted
Latrobe Valley[5] Vic 81001 Not Counted
Rockhampton Qld 77878 Not Counted
Bundaberg Qld 69036 Not Counted
Bunbury WA 68248 Not Counted
Darwin NT 63,766 Each 50/50 split
Hervey Bay Qld 60807 Not Counted
Wagga Wagga NSW 58610 Not Counted
Coffs Harbour NSW 53401 Not Counted
Albury-Wodonga NSW/Vic 53026 50/50 split
Gladstone Qld 51158 Not Counted
Mildura Vic 50522 Not Counted
Shepparton Vic 49859 Not Counted
Tamworth NSW 47595 Not Counted
Port Macquarie NSW 44313 Not Counted
Orange NSW 39329 Not Counted
Dubbo NSW 38037 Not Counted
Geraldton WA 36958 Not Counted
Nowra-Bomaderry NSW 34479 Not Counted
Bathurst NSW 34303 Not Counted
Warrnambool Vic 33922 Not Counted
Lismore NSW 32494 Not Counted
Kalgoorlie-Boulder WA 32390 Not Counted
When removing the people who have already been counted in ozTAM figures. There are still a total of 3,859,831 viewers that are not counted under your continued ozTAM only figures nonsense. Of which 73% or 2,798,904 are in Rugby League based towns and 27% or 1,060,927are in AFL based towns. Even if you AFL boys want to take all the 50/50's you still look bad
When looking at the above figures surely you cannot dispute why regional figures have to be counted in this thread and why NRL will ensure they are tabled. Especially, when NRL has sides in the towns where around 40% of these people live, Newcastle, Canberra, Wollongong and North Qld. So that is regional included as far as I can see and I do not care for any responses that don’t back themselves with supporting evidence.
Now onto ozTAM - I agree with one thing that Truthsayer say, it should one grooup of counters, but the group has to be way bigger then the 5 city count to include regional australia and based upon the population per state.
All AFL fans seem happy to use ozTAM figures as they can be manipulated to favour AFL. Beaussie wanted to suggest that my previous figures were incorrect where I suggested that ozTAM figures are not even close to a fair in representing regional Australian viewer. I had suggested that by using ozTAM only to represent the entire country, it was heavily AFL bias as based upon the 3025 homes used for counts, 55% are counted in Melb, Adel and Perth, even though these AFL based states only represent around 45% of our countries population. Beaussies problem with my figures was there are a number of AFL supporters amongst NSW and QLD. I am happy to go with that, if we can all agree that there are also a number of Rugby League fans in AFL areas as well.
Therefore, if we only use ozTAM, we are still in a position that 55% of the population is represented by what 45% of the country’s population watch. If the counters were based upon the true population ie 55% were in NSW, QLD and 45% of counters were in Vic, SA and Perth, then we would get a more accurate reflection of what people watch. Eg if there is more AFL viewers in NSW, QLD, then NRL viewers in Vic, SA and Perth then this would be reflected by what the counters watch. However the AFL ratings are inflated as 55% of the 3025 homes used for counting can only watch AFL as in Vic, SA or Perth, Rugby League is not televised, not only is it inflated incorrectly by population, it is inflated as even if they wanted to watch Rugby League, they can’t. You cannot deny that ozTAM is significantly bias to AFL.
AFL is televised in all 5 city’s. It has been suggested that there is no supporter/viewers of Rugby League in these states, if you look at the numbers who watch the State of Origins it paints a different picture. 18% or 1,203,000 of the ozTAM viewers came from states that don’t apparently watch Rugby League.
It has also been suggested the ratings are there to support AFL to be watched in Brisbane and Sydney. Friday is the only time when they are both truly on at the same time. I ask you this, how many AFL viewers are there in Sydney and Brisbane when the games are played at the same time, see below and then let’s chat.
I have seen you guy’s whinge about the so called AFL delayed game on Friday Night as an excuse when your numbers are down. The AFL game, which this Friday is telecast at 5:30pm Perth, 8pm Adel and 8:30pm Melb. It is definitely live in Adelaide and Perth with their time differences and has a whole 50 minute delay in Melbourne compare to our second Friday night game, which is delayed 2 hours. The closest we are going to get with comparing apples with apples to compare the AFL Friday Night game with the NRL live game.
I have also included the Sunday figures below as both codes have a game on, however to my previous point about how many viewers are there in Syd and Bris when they are played at the same time, it should be noted that in Brisbane and Sydney they are not telecast at the same. I will concede (as they can’t) that nobody watches league in Melb, Adel and Perth. So now let’s look at how the figures stand when played head to head for the last three weeks, without regional viewers to keep you all happy.
Figures From:
http://www.tvtonight.com.au/category/ratings
Week 31 – Close, but no cigar AFL
11 Nine’s Live Friday Night Football Nine 714,000 454,000 *** 260,000 *** ***
16 Seven’s AFL: Rnd 19: North Melbourne Vs Carlton Seven 529,000 8,000 305,000 6,000 120,000 90,000
30 Nine’s Friday Night Football Nine 281,000 184,000 *** 97,000 *** ***
22 Nine’s Sunday Football Nine 468,000 304,000 *** 164,000 *** ***
27 Seven’s AFL: Rnd 18: Melbourne Vs Hawthorn Seven 369,000 41,000 208,000 24,000 90,000 6,000
Week 30 – Not even a comparison the 2 hours delayed game was only shy by 80 K, but you pipped us by 16k on the Sunday well done
9 Nine’s Live Friday Night Football Nine 819,000 504,000 *** 315,000 *** ***
19 Seven’s AFL: Rnd 18: St Kilda Vs Adelaide Seven 496,000 16,000 251,000 17,000 158,000 53,000 21 Nine’s Friday Night Football Nine 411,000 314,000 *** 97,000 *** ***
17 Seven’s AFL: Rnd 17: Brisbane Vs Geelong Seven 508,000 5,000 262,000 77,000 96,000 68,000
20 Nine’s Sunday Football Nine 492,000 322,000 *** 169,000 *** ***
Week 29 –You got us by 101K on Friday, well done. We got you on Sunday.
11 Seven’s AFL: Rnd 17: Adelaide Vs Essendon Seven 690,000 16,000 416,000 14,000 181,000 64,000
16 Nine’s Live Friday Night Football Nine 589,000 302,000 *** 287,000 *** ***
34 Nine’s Friday Night Football Nine 279,000 177,000 *** 102,000 *** ***
18 Nine’s Sunday Football Nine 409,000 282,000 *** 127,000 *** ***
20 Seven’s AFL: Rnd 16: Port Adelaide Vs St Kilda Seven 384,000 18,000 186,000 6,000 110,000 65,000
Overall Rugby League 3,491,000 viewers (This only includes the NRL live Game) , AFL 2,976,000 Viewer.
Now for my opinion lets combine the regional:
Figures from
http://www.thinktv.com.au/content_commo ... eports.seo
Week 31 Preliminary: Sorry no mention of AFL, however Friday Night NRL is in the Regional top 40 and when combined with ozTAM LIVE FRIDAY NIGHT FOOTBALL 1,173
Week 30 – Sorry no mention of AFL, however Friday Night NRL is in the Regional top 40 and when combined with LIVE FRIDAY NIGHT FOOTBALL 1,354,000 viewer
Week 29 – Sorry no mention of AFL, however Friday Night NRL is in the Regional top 40
Remembering that Pay TV paid around half of your bill in the last negotiation and none of the above take Pay TV in to consideration, I’d say CHECK MATE as rugby League wins hands down, no disputing that, end of discussion. Don’t give me excuses now, give me facts as they are certainly stacked up for Rugby League, when you also include Pay TV.